CITR considers peer review an essential component of responsible scholarly publishing.
The review process is designed to provide independent scientific assessment while helping editors determine whether submitted research meets appropriate standards of rigor, relevance, and reporting.
Reviewers Consider
- Scientific question
- Study design
- Methodological rigor
- Data quality
- Statistical or analytical approach
- Interpretation
- Reproducibility
- Ethical considerations
- Originality
- Translational significance
- Limitations
Constructive Evaluation
Reviewers are encouraged to distinguish between essential concerns affecting scientific validity and recommendations intended primarily to improve clarity or presentation.